9477 / 2027

Lesson 1 of 9 / Practical and data skills

Plan an investigation that answers the question

What makes a comparison fair enough to explain?

I can choose variables, controls, repeats and analysis that address a biological hypothesis.

About 6 min

Make a guess. You are not marked.

You measure one enzyme reaction three times from the same tube. Are these three independent repeats?

  1. They are if the readings agree closely.
  2. Each needs a fresh mixture.
  3. Three readings means three repeats.
Show the answer

Each needs a fresh mixture.

Re-reading one tube checks the measurement, not the reaction. Independent repeats are set up separately.

The key idea

Change a defined independent variable, measure a useful response and explain how other influences will be controlled.

Work with the evidence

Change one cause and measure its response

pH 5pH 6pH 7pH 8Same controlled temperature

Change: Choose buffered pH values over a useful range. This is the independent variable.

Schematic of comparable treatments, not a complete apparatus setup. Each pH needs independent repeats and suitable gas measurement.

Explanation

Start with a testable relationship, such as how pH affects the initial rate of a catalase-catalysed reaction. The independent variable is what you deliberately change. The dependent variable is the response you measure. Make both operational: state the pH values used and how gas volume over time will give a rate.

Identify variables that could also affect the response. For this enzyme investigation, keep temperature, enzyme amount, substrate concentration and total reaction volume consistent. A buffer controls pH, a water bath controls temperature, and fixed measured volumes make the comparisons reproducible. State how, not simply "keep everything constant".

Use a suitable range and intervals, with repeats at each value. A preliminary trial can identify a workable range, a measurable time interval and any practical difficulty. Repeating independent reaction mixtures estimates variation better than repeatedly reading one unchanged measurement. Keep biological replicates distinct from repeated readings of the same specimen.

A control treatment answers a specific alternative explanation. A mixture without active enzyme can reveal gas production unrelated to the intended enzyme reaction. Keep its other relevant conditions comparable. A controlled variable and a control treatment have different roles.

Plan the analysis before collecting data: calculate a rate for each repeat, summarise the repeats, plot rate against pH and evaluate the pattern. This ensures that the measurements can answer the original question.

Assess the actual hazards and exposure routes. For example, splashes of an irritant hydrogen peroxide solution can harm eyes. Using the school-specified dilute concentration and small volumes, wearing suitable eye protection and transferring carefully reduce exposure. Link each precaution to its hazard and follow the school's material-specific risk assessment. Accurate apparatus handling also needs supervised laboratory practice.

Step by step
  1. 1

    Define the comparison

    Name the biological question, independent variable and measurable response.

  2. 2

    Protect the comparison

    Specify controls, a useful range and independent repeats.

  3. 3

    Plan the conclusion

    Choose calculations, presentation and risk precautions before collecting data.

Worked example

Work through the evidence

A student compares catalase at pH 5 and pH 8, but uses twice as much enzyme at pH 8. Can a higher rate at pH 8 be attributed to pH?

One way to explain it

No. Enzyme amount is a confounding variable. Use the same enzyme concentration and volume at both pH values, keep other relevant factors consistent, and repeat independent reactions before comparing their rates.

Why this answer works
  • Name the specific confounder.
  • Explain why it can affect the dependent variable.
  • Specify a correction that isolates the intended comparison.

Watch out for this

A student says: "A control means making every tube identical." What is wrong with this?

Show the answer

The independent variable must differ. Relevant other conditions should be held consistent, while a control treatment is chosen to test a particular alternative explanation.

Check your understanding

Which is an independent repeat of an enzyme reaction?

  1. Preparing a fresh reaction mixture under the same specified conditions
  2. Changing enzyme amount for the second pH value
  3. Reading the final gas volume from the same tube three times and taking the mean
Show the answer

Preparing a fresh reaction mixture under the same specified conditions

Independent preparations help estimate variation between experimental runs.

Quick recall

Card 1 of 3. Answer in your head, then check.

What makes a comparison fair enough to explain?

You can return to this lesson any time.