9477 / 2027

Lesson 4 of 6 / Evolution, species and phylogeny

Species and reproductive isolation

How can populations stop exchanging genes?

I can explain the biological species concept, its limits and allopatric/sympatric speciation.

  • I can explain the biological species concept and its limitations.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9477, Core 4(h). Explain the biological species concept and its limitations.

  • I can explain allopatric and sympatric speciation.Syllabus

    Syllabus 9477, Core 4(j). Explain allopatric and sympatric speciation.

About 8 min

Make a guess. You are not marked.

A new river splits a population of mice in two. Are they now two species?

  1. They are, from the moment the river forms.
  2. Not until they are reproductively isolated.
  3. Species cannot form this way.
Show the answer

Not until they are reproductively isolated.

The river stops gene flow. Speciation happens only if they diverge enough that they cannot interbreed when reunited.

The key idea

Reduced gene flow allows divergence; speciation is established when reproductive isolation separates lineages, not merely when a barrier appears.

Explore the idea

Separation is the start of the question

One geographical regionBABABAInterbreeding connects the groupsUse breeding evidence, not colour alone

The starting population contains variation and exchanges genes through interbreeding. Colours distinguish variants; they do not define different species.

Before fertilisation, barriers can prevent mating or gamete fusion. After fertilisation, low hybrid survival or fertility can restrict gene flow. A biological species concept is harder to apply to fossils, asexual organisms and populations whose breeding cannot be tested.

Original conceptual populations. The two clusters are a drawing aid and do not themselves imply geographical isolation. The cross means strongly reduced gene flow, not that every real species boundary is perfectly absolute. The contact outcome is evidence supplied to the model, not a guaranteed result of waiting.

Explanation

The biological species concept groups natural populations whose members can interbreed and produce viable, fertile offspring, while being reproductively isolated from other such groups. It focuses on gene flow rather than appearance alone.

The concept is difficult to apply to fossils, asexual organisms and geographically separated populations whose mating cannot be observed. Hybridisation between otherwise distinct groups also complicates sharp boundaries. A classification should state which evidence and species concept are being used.

In allopatric speciation, a geographical barrier reduces gene flow. Mutation, selection and other population processes can then produce divergence. If reproductive barriers persist when contact resumes, separate species may have formed. Geographical separation alone does not instantly create a new species.

In sympatric speciation, reproductive isolation develops within the same geographical region. Behavioural differences such as mating signals or timing, and physiological differences affecting compatibility, can reduce interbreeding. Host preference or ecological differentiation can contribute; in some plants polyploidy provides a further mechanism, though the central required idea is isolation without a geographical split.

Pre-fertilisation barriers can prevent mating or fertilisation; post-fertilisation barriers can reduce hybrid survival or fertility. Explain the barrier's effect on gene exchange rather than merely naming it.

Adaptive radiation is the rapid evolution of many species from one ancestral species, each adapted to a different niche. It often follows the colonisation of a new area with many unoccupied niches and few competitors, such as an island group. Populations on different islands or using different food sources are isolated, face different selection pressures and diverge. The finches of the Galapagos Islands, with beaks suited to different foods, are a well-known example.

Step by step
  1. 1

    Identify the gene-flow barrier

    Geography, behaviour or physiological incompatibility?

  2. 2

    Explain divergence

    Separate populations accumulate different inherited changes.

  3. 3

    Test persistent isolation

    Would gene exchange resume if contact occurred?

Worked example

Work through the evidence

Two bird populations live together but respond only to different courtship songs and rarely mate across groups. Which mode could this support?

One way to explain it

Sympatric divergence through behavioural reproductive isolation, if the barrier is persistent and supports separate gene pools.

Why this answer works
  • There is no required geographical separation.
  • Song difference matters because it changes mating and gene flow.

Watch out for this

A student says: "Two populations become different species the moment a river separates them." What is wrong with this?

Show the answer

The barrier reduces gene flow, but speciation requires sufficient reproductive divergence, not just location.

Check your understanding

Why is the biological species concept hard to apply to fossils?

  1. Every fossil is necessarily a different species.
  2. Fossils show adaptive radiation, which proves that every fossil belongs to its own species.
  3. Their natural interbreeding and fertility cannot be directly tested.
  4. Fossils have no anatomical evidence.
Show the answer

Their natural interbreeding and fertility cannot be directly tested.

Reproductive criteria are usually unavailable for extinct specimens.

Quick recall

Card 1 of 3. Answer in your head, then check.

How can populations stop exchanging genes?

You can return to this lesson any time.