Why disarmament talks failed

G2 Full History - syllabus K227, 2027

What this lesson teaches

  • I can explain the reasons World War II broke out in Europe and in the Asia-Pacific.

    Syllabus K227, War in Europe and the Asia-Pacific, Learning Outcomes. Explain the reasons for the outbreak of World War II in Europe and the Asia-Pacific.

Make a guess

At the 1932 disarmament talks, Germany asked for equal treatment on weapons. What do you think France wanted first?

  1. To let Germany rearm in return for trade deals.
  2. Firm promises of help if Germany attacked it again.
  3. To cut its own army straight away to match Germany's.
Show the answer

Firm promises of help if Germany attacked it again.

France feared a stronger Germany. It wanted security guarantees before accepting any change that let Germany catch up.

Germany wanted equal treatment on weapons, France wanted to feel safe first, and they never agreed on rules that satisfied both.

Disarmament means reducing armed forces and weapons, also called armaments. The World Disarmament Conference opened in 1932 to agree wider limits. Germany argued that the Treaty of Versailles limited its military far more than other countries'. It demanded equality: either other countries should cut their forces, or Germany should be allowed more.

France feared another German attack. If Germany rebuilt its forces while France cut its own, France would be more at risk. So French leaders wanted security guarantees, reliable promises of help if France was attacked, before agreeing to any change.

Both sides talked about security, but wanted different things. To reach a deal, they still had to agree actual limits, how to check countries kept them, and what would happen if a country broke the rules.

No workable agreement was reached. In October 1933, Hitler used the equality dispute as his reason to walk out of the conference and announce that Germany was leaving the League of Nations. He then pursued rearmament, building up Germany's armed forces. In 1935, he openly brought back conscription, compulsory military service, breaking Versailles. The failed talks ended hopes of controlling weapons by agreement and made an arms race easier.

1932
World Disarmament Conference opens.
October 1933
Germany leaves the conference and the League.
1935
Hitler brings back conscription, breaking Versailles.

Real examples to use

Walk-out, 14 October 1933

Germany left the Disarmament Conference and gave notice that it was leaving the League of Nations on the same day.

Conscription, 16 March 1935

Hitler announced an army of 36 divisions, about 550,000 men, against the 100,000 allowed by Versailles.

Anglo-German Naval Agreement, 18 June 1935

Britain agreed that Germany's navy could be 35 per cent of the size of the Royal Navy, breaking the Versailles limits without asking France.

Worked example: Agreeing on words, not rules

In December 1932, the powers agreed Germany should have equal rights within a secure system. The details were never settled.

  1. Germany wanted its unequal limits removed.
  2. France wanted to know what would protect it.
  3. Shared words did not fix actual limits, so Hitler could walk away.

Watch out for this

Germany broke a disarmament treaty that all countries signed in 1932.

No general disarmament treaty was agreed. The talks failed, and Germany left in 1933.

Check your understanding

Why did France resist giving Germany equal weapons?

  1. It feared a stronger Germany would attack it again.
  2. It planned to invade Germany before it could rearm.
  3. It had already cut its army to Germany's size.
Show the answer

It feared a stronger Germany would attack it again.

Yes. France wanted security guarantees first.

Sources and context

Background reading for this chapter.

  • A public commitment to consultation

    Anglo-German declaration signed by Hitler and Chamberlain, 30 September 1938, as read in Chamberlain's House of Commons statement on 3 October. Paraphrase of the declaration, not the whole speech.

  • Chamberlain defends Munich

    Neville Chamberlain, British prime minister, addressing the House of Commons, 3 October 1938, after returning from Munich. Paraphrase of passages on the agreement, Czechoslovakia, future peace and rearmament.

  • Churchill challenges the settlement

    Winston Churchill, Conservative MP and critic of the government's appeasement policy, speaking in the House of Commons, 5 October 1938. Paraphrase of passages on deterrence and Czechoslovakia.

  • A record of Hitler's private discussion

    Colonel Friedrich Hossbach's memorandum, dated 10 November 1937, recording Hitler's meeting with senior military and foreign-policy officials on 5 November. Paraphrase of the recorded discussion; the memorandum is not a word-for-word transcript.

  • Munich Pact, 29 September 1938, clauses 1-4

    Munich Pact, dated 29 September 1938 and signed by Germany, Britain, France and Italy in the early hours of 30 September. Paraphrase of clauses 1-4; Czechoslovakia was later represented on the implementation commission.

  • a cartoon about Munich, October 1938

    An original cartoon drawn for these notes in the style of a British newspaper cartoon by a critic of appeasement, published in early October 1938, days after the Munich Agreement. It is not a copy of a real cartoon.

  • Munich Pact, 29 September 1938, clauses 1-4

    Extract from the agreement signed at Munich by Germany, the United Kingdom, France and Italy, dated 29 September 1938 and signed in the early hours of 30 September. Czechoslovakia was not represented at the conference. Text from the Avalon Project (English text as published by the British government).

  • Chamberlain in the House of Commons

    Extract from Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain's statement in the House of Commons, 3 October 1938, opening the debate on the Munich Agreement. Hansard, House of Commons, 3 October 1938. Parliamentary copyright, reproduced under the Open Parliament Licence.

  • Churchill in the House of Commons

    Extract from Winston Churchill's speech in the House of Commons debate on the Munich Agreement, 5 October 1938. Churchill was a Conservative MP and the best-known critic of the government's policy. Hansard, House of Commons, 5 October 1938. Parliamentary copyright, reproduced under the Open Parliament Licence.

  • a record of Hitler's secret meeting

    Extract from the memorandum by Colonel Friedrich Hossbach, Hitler's military adjutant, of a secret meeting between Hitler and his foreign minister and military chiefs on 5 November 1937, dated 10 November 1937. It was written from memory, not as a word-for-word record, and was used as evidence at the Nuremberg trials. English translation from Documents on German Foreign Policy, published by the US State Department; text from the Avalon Project.

The Wise Otter

Getting your study space ready